Weber Summit vs Genesis II are among the company’s most popular high-end models. They are quite expensive, but they do come with amazing features and capabilities. Now, the question is, which one should you choose? Weber Summit and Weber Genesis II are two very different styles of grills.
Continue reading to understand better about
- How each of these grills works
- How much cooking space that is available on each model
- Which Weber grill that is generally easier to set-up and use
- The features of Weber Summit and Weber Genesis II
- The cooking performance of Weber Summit vs Genesis II
- Which high-end Weber grill that is generally more recommended
Weber Summit: Overview
When we are talking about Weber Summit, it should be noted that this is a kamado-style charcoal grill. This unit is quite different from the likes of Weber Genesis 310 Vs 410, which are liquid propane grills. This unit uses charcoal to generate heat and smoke to cook your food.
Weber Summit is actually the first kamado grill of the company. While it is categorized as a kamado grill, it is still uniquely Weber. It comes with the cooking abilities of a kettle grill and the smoking power of a smoker. Not only that; it also comes with bells and whistles that add even more value.
However, this model does not have a traditional ceramic body. Instead, Weber Summit has an air-insulated body which consists of inner and outer metal walls that are separated from each other by a sealed gap. Some people may think that such a design won’t work, but it does work. Effectively. The grill is able to maintain low temperatures for smoking for over 10 hours without needing a refuel. It is very efficient.
There is a notable difference in the available cooking space on Weber Summit vs Genesis II. The kamado grill can easily cook more food at once with its 452-square-inch total cooking space. However, it is without any additional warming rack or side burner. Depending on your needs and purposes, this may or may not be a problem.
Weber Summit: Features
The construction of Weber Summit uses porcelain-coated stainless steel on all of its parts, including the body, cooking grates, and vents. Besides enhancing the appearance, the porcelain coating also greatly enhances the durability and ease of cleaning. Compared to the cheaper Weber kettle grills, Weber Summit looks and feels a lot more premium.
This grill is also armed with a piezo electric gas ignition system. It uses a 16-oz liquid propane bottle to produce the initial flame to light the charcoal. The gar burner is located right under the lower charcoal grate.
You can choose to start the charcoal with the grate in the upper position (which will cause the burn time to be longer) or in the lower position (which has a shorter burn time). After you have started the charcoal and turned off the gas burner, you can close the lid to pre-heat.
The lid is hinged and spring-loaded. It is surprisingly easy to lift. Weber Summit also comes with Weber Gourmet BBQ System cooking grates which have a removable center section where you can insert a wide range of accessories, such as a pizza stone or an Ebelskiver pan.
Weber Summit is able to do everything that a typical kamado grill can do, while at the same time offering a very spacious cooking space. It is also well-constructed. People who have never used a kamado grill may have to go through some learning curve, but fortunately Weber Summit is quite easy to start and operate.
Weber Summit: Performance
You should expect different things when cooking between Weber Summit vs Genesis II. In terms of versatility and practicality, Weber Summit is probably not as good as Weber Genesis II. However, as a kamado-style grill, it is able to provide a unique grilled and smoked flavor to your food. Plus, it has a great cooking power, and it has enough space to create a two-zone setup easily.
When the charcoal grate is set in the lower position, Weber Summit performs similarly to a standard Weber kettle grill. Meanwhile, when cooking with the charcoal grate set in the upper position, Weber Summit still feels similar to a standard Weber kettle grill, but the cooking temperature is dramatically higher because the burning charcoal is much closer to the food.
However, keep in mind that you need to distribute the coals as evenly as possible. As the coals are much closer to the food, uneven hot spots will also create bigger problems. If some coals are already burning in red while some others are still jet-black, your food may get burnt in some places while still raw in other places.
In the end, Weber Summit is more of a premium aspirational product. The company is clearly aware of this, as they sell Weber Summit in specialty markets instead of general stores. It is a luxury grill that can do a bit of everything. It can grill at high temperatures, and it can be dialed down quickly for smoking.
Weber Genesis II: Overview
Weber Genesis II is very different from Weber Summit. It is a gas grill. While it can’t smoke your food, it offers several distinctive benefits, such as easy operation, clean cooking, and fast heat-up. Weber Genesis II has carried on the company’s legacy of high quality in its compact yet very durable unit.
The construction is very robust. Both the cooking grates and the lid are porcelain-enameled. They feel very durable and are easy to wipe clean. Weber Genesis II also has an enclosed storage cabinet and a side table where you can put all your cooking tools.
Weber Genesis II will need some assembly before you can use it for the first time. The process is actually not too difficult. However, you will need some time to decipher the pictures in the provided guide. The assembly may take about 1 – 2 hours. Fortunately, you only need a wrench and a Phillips screwdriver for that. The bolts, nuts, and battery are included in the box.
As mentioned above, Weber Summit vs Genesis II have different cooking areas. The smallest Weber Genesis II, E-210, has a limited primary cooking space, which is ‘only’ 380 square inches. However, it does comes with a warming rack with a space of 114 square inches. The larger models, E-335 and E-435, are equipped with side burners. So, even though the primary cooking space is smaller, Weber Genesis II still has the versatility to prepare multiple foods at once.
Weber Genesis II: Features
One of the most highlighted features of Weber gas grills is the Flavorizer Bars. It is V-shaped porcelain-enameled steel plates which are located under the cooking grates. It has two purposes: to vaporize drippings in order to enhance the food’s flavor, and to funnel the stuff that can’t be vaporized into the grease tray.
This design is really good because it helps to reduce flare-ups and prevent the burners from getting clogged. The Flavorizer Bars, together with the heat deflector, also help to maintain even heat distribution.
Weber Genesis II is known for its durability and longevity. The firebox is made of rust-proof cast-aluminum. This is far more durable than basic carbon steel fireboxes that are typically found in budget models. It is also better in holding heat. Weber Genesis II also has a welded tube frame that is very sturdy.
Optionally, Weber Genesis II can be used with the iGrill 3 app-connected thermometer. This system will allow you to monitor the cooking temperature and the doneness of your food in real time. It is a fancy feature, but it can be quite handy at times.
Weber Genesis II: Performance
Weber Genesis II is very easy and simple to operate. Once everything is assembled, you only need to press the knob, turn it leftwards to the lightning symbol, and press the ignition button. The grill will start right away. You won’t ever need to make repeated tries to start the grill.
When tested to cook a wide range of foods, including sausages, steak strips, burgers, salmon fillets, and flatbreads, Weber Genesis II performed admirably well. The performance is very consistent and reliable. The heat distribution is completely even. There was no issue with hot spots or uneven cooking.
The resulted foods are very tasty. While they don’t exactly have a smoked flavor like the foods that are grilled with wood pellets or coals, they still have a nice grilled flavor. Plus, the cooking process is much cleaner.
Once you have finished cooking, Weber Grill II is very easy to clean. The cooking grates can be scraped clean without much effort. Even after cooking foods with lots of drippings, there is no problem with sticking. The grease tray is easily removable and disposable.
Weber Summit vs Genesis II
In general, Weber Genesis II is more recommended for most people. It is much easier to operate, and it is also easy to clean and maintain. Cooking with the gas grill is cleaner, too. The cooking performance is great. On the other hand, Weber Summit is more of a specialty item, suitable if you don’t mind spending a lot of money for a kamado grill that can add a smoked flavor to your food.