George Foreman Indoor Grill vs Hamilton Beach Indoor Grill

In the time of quarantine, you’re spending most of your time at home. Sometimes, it can be hard to find things to do at home and keep yourself excited. Well, why don’t you try buying an indoor grill machine and make a small barbecue party with your family?

Today, we’re going to review and compare two of the most popular grill brands out there, George Foreman Indoor Grill and Hamilton Beach Indoor Grill. While both brands have different kinds of grills, we focus more on grills that can prepare meals for 6 people. Remember that you’re using this grill to make a little barbecue party for your family, so 6 sounds about right. 

For that purpose in mind, we’re going to review George Foreman 6-Serving Removable Plate Grill (George Foreman GRP99) and Hamilton Beach 6-Serving Removable Plate Grill (Hamilton Beach 25361). Without further ado, let’s jump right into it.

George Foreman GRP99 Review

Two decades after retiring from boxing, his indoor electric grills have kept George Foreman relevant and famous over the years. The George Foreman GRP99 model is one of the best indoor electric grills from the George Foreman line.

George Foreman GRP99 is priced at $84.99 on Amazon and it currently holds a rating of 3.8 stars out of 5 from 997 customer reviews. It weighs 12.8 pounds and has a product dimension of 17 x 7 x 14 inches.

George Foreman GRP99 is manufactured by Spectrum Brands. It is a pretty old model, it has been listed on Amazon since October 2001 and ranked #43 on Amazon’s Best Selling Contact Grills. This model comes with a one-year Warranty from product defects.

This grill model comes with a digital display, dishwasher-safe components, and a temperature selector that allow you to set a timer and control the temperatures. Most food cooks in under 10 minutes with this grill. 

One of the main selling points of George Foreman GRP99 is its easiness to be cleaned up. The design of this grill makes it possible not to produce any greasy mess while cooking. In addition, the grill plate, drip tray, and other components of this grill are dishwasher safe. 

 George Foreman Indoor GrillHamilton Beach Indoor Grill
Best offerCheck priceCheck price
Product Dimensions22.2 x 20.5 x 13 inches
12.4 x 16.7 x 6.8 inches
Shipping Weight21 pounds
8.14 pounds

The grill plates are removable and equipped with touch handles that make it super easy to be cleaned up. Overall, it just takes 4 minutes to clean up this grill after you’ve done using it. That’s better than most grills on the market that take up to 10 minutes to clean up. 

The cooking area in this grill is about 108 square inches, enough to cook 6 small burgers or 3 large steaks. Its raised surface allows grease and oil to drip down into the collecting tray, and the covered clamshell design keeps spatter and mess off your counter. The manufacturer claims that this grill removes 42% of fat while cooking.

However, there’s only one drawback of this grill. While this indoor grill is great at cooking beef and making tasty hamburgers, it doesn’t fare quite as well when cooking chicken. If you cook chicken in this grill, it will most likely come out as rubbery and not tender. 

The most logical explanation might have to do with the fact that this grill removes fat and grease. While the things that make chicken so tender are its fats and juices. This grill is also not designed to cook eggs or pancakes.

Despite its weakness, George Foreman GRP99 is still one of the best grills under $100 that’s available on the market. If you want to remove fats in your diet, this grill is definitely the one to go.

Hamilton Beach 225361 Review

Hamilton Beach 225361 is usually listed at $89.99 but it’s currently on sale for just $69.99. It holds a rating of 4.5 stars out of 5 from 3,318 customer reviews. It’s currently the #1 Best Selling Contact Grills on Amazon.

This model is made of stainless steel and it weighs 8.14 pounds and has a product dimension of 12.4 x 16.7 x 6.8 inches. This grill is manufactured by Hamilton Beach themselves and comes with a one-year Warranty for product defects.

Similar to George Foreman grill, this model is also easy to clean up. It comes with a removable indoor grill hood, plate, and extra-large drip tray that are all dishwasher safe. The extra-large drip tray will make sure that no juice will mess up your counter. 

One of the main selling points of this grill is its high searing temperature. It comes with an adjustable temperature control that ranges from 200 degree Celsius to high searing temperature of 450 degree Celsius. Because of this, you can get the outdoor grill taste with an indoor grill.

Hamilton Beach 225361 has a 118 square inches grilling surface. With this grill, you can cook steaks, barbecue, hamburgers, grilled chicken, fish, pizza, vegetable, fruits, and other kinds of food for 6 people. It’s also great for Paleo and Keto diets. 

Another awesome feature of this grill is its viewing window. The convenient window in the lid lets you watch as your food is being cooked inside the grill. It makes it much easier for you to control the food, so that it won’t be overcooked. 

Overall, Hamilton Beach 225361 is one of the best grills you can get in this price range of under $100. This grill has become the best-selling grills on Amazon for a reason, right?

George Foreman Indoor Grill vs Hamilton Beach Indoor Grill

- 15+ Servings - It’s tailgate time! The 240 square inches of circular grilling surface lets you make over 15 servings for large groups of people
- George Tough Nonstick Coating - There’s a lot to love about this nonstick coating; it’s durable, easy to clean, and removes the need for butter and oil
- Indoor/Outdoor Removable Stand - Don’t let the weather keep you from the glory of grilling; the easy-to-remove stand takes you from patio to countertop in no time
- Adjustable Temperature Control - The temperature probe lets you choose from five heat settings to get the best results on any kind of food
- Locks in Juices and Flavors: Sear at 450 degrees or use adjustable temperature dial to grill at lower heat for optimal grilling results.
- Enjoy Grilling All Year Long: This Indoor Grill With Hood Has a High Searing Heat That Locks in Juices and Flavors
- Keep an Eye on Your Food: This Indoor Grill With Hood Comes With a Convenient Window in Lid Lets You Watch Food Cook While Keeping Heat Inside.
- Less Mess: Extra-Large Drip Tray Catches Juices so They Don't Spill on Your Counter and It's Dishwasher Safe for Easy Cleaning.


After reviewing George Foreman indoor grill and Hamilton Beach indoor grill, it’s time to make a verdict. Both of these models are the best model of electric indoor grills that both companies have to offer. 

If you’re on a diet and looking for a grill that removes fat, then you should buy the George Foreman GRP99 indoor grill. But if you’re looking for an indoor grill that can emulate the taste of an outdoor grill, then you should go with the Hamilton Beach 225361 model.

Both of these grills come in at a similar price range and both of them are great grills made for different purposes. So, it all comes down to your personal preferences and choices. But if we have to choose one, we’d go with the Hamilton Beach 225361 model for its larger cooking surface and high searing temperature that matches outdoor grills.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *